Dr. Octagon

THE STRANGE CAREER OF O. S. FOWLER, POPULARIZER OF PHRENOLOGY AND YANKEE FENG SHUI
DISCUSSED
Dr. Johann Spurzheim, Consultations with Walt Whitman, Self-Pleasure and the Dangerous Dissipation of Vital Forces, Eugenics, Abolition, Health Colonies, Creative and Sexual Science, Love Potions, Pragmatic Transcendentalists, The Mystical Spiritual Evolution of Humanity, Terrestrial Angels, The Public’s Gullibility, Forms of Quackery, Toxic Exhalations, Principles of Mortar-Making, Anti-Obscenity Crusaders, “Fowler’s Folly”

Dr. Octagon

John Adamian
Facebook icon Share via Facebook Twitter icon Share via Twitter

For much of the 1800s, Orson Squire Fowler was America’s foremost practitioner of phrenology. He pressed his fingertips against the skulls of the most famous men of nineteenth-century ­America—presidents, generals, philosophers, poets, ­artists, revolutionaries, criminals, and clergymen. Carefully he’d explore the contours of the cranium, measuring from ear to ear, looking for subtle protrusions, reflecting on the proportions of the lobes. By the time of his death, Fowler would be as well known for his writings on sex and for the obscenity charges brought against him. But another part of his legacy can still be seen today, in the unusual houses he inspired people to build. According to Fowler, life in an eight-sided house was healthier and happier than in the square variety. He was a tireless promoter of octagonal home design, which he thought would essentially improve humanity.

Some considered Fowler a con artist. He was called a “fraud” and a “charlatan” in the pages of the Chicago Tribune. He claimed to have a deep understanding of individual human destiny—the future written in head bumps. He may have thought of himself as a scientist, but he self-promoted like a sideshow barker. He exhibited brains and other parts collected from all over the world at his popular Phrenological Cabinet, located on Broadway near Canal Street in New York.

Fowler sometimes conducted de­monstrations while blindfolded, to show disbelieving crowds that he could identify the heads of living robbers and degenerates who were brought into the crowd as part of his routine. (A colleague later alleged that this was a sham.) He was a peculiar and peripatetic figure, a public intellectual and a lifestyle guru. He traveled all over America and Europe in the name of phrenology, deducing people’s fundamental natures. If he looked at your forehead and told you, in grave tones, not to become a ­lawyer—because of your poor reasoning and underdeveloped language skills—you listened. He professed to know how shapes corresponded to deep and mysterious aspects of the personality.

It makes sense, then, that one of Fowler’s other great obsessions also involved the shape of things. When he urged Americans to live in octagonal houses, they obeyed. He wasn’t an architect, but thousands of people­ took his advice and built eight-sided abodes. The fad mushroomed in America during the mid-1800s. You can still see the houses today: a few thousand remain in New England, New York, and the Midwest. Depending on how ornate or ­simple the original buildings were, and how they’ve withstood the past century or so, they may resemble wedding cakes, enormous tiered hives, crude ­giant gems, or what Claes Oldenburg might...

You have reached your article limit

Sign up for a digital subscription and continue reading all new issues, plus our entire archives, for just $1.50/month.

More Reads
Essays

A Devil Obsessed Conglomeration of Christian Misfits

William Giraldi
Essays

Polish Movie Posters: One of the Great Secrets of Twentieth Century Pop Art

Michael Atkinson
Essays

Cathedral Head

Victoria Nelson
More